1
00:00:01,543 --> 00:00:03,211
Previously on Medium:

2
00:00:03,294 --> 00:00:04,295
DEVALOS He's dying.

3
00:00:04,379 --> 00:00:08,425
The mayor, the governor, they all want me to step in.

4
00:00:08,508 --> 00:00:10,969
They gave him his job back.

5
00:00:11,052 --> 00:00:13,596
(laughing) That's amazing!

6
00:00:13,680 --> 00:00:15,598
Does that mean that you get your job back?

7
00:00:15,682 --> 00:00:17,392
As soon as I want.

8
00:00:17,475 --> 00:00:18,393
JOE: Who was that?

9
00:00:18,476 --> 00:00:19,269
MEGAN: Terry Cavanaugh.

10
00:00:19,352 --> 00:00:21,646
The John D. Rockefeller of solar energy.

11
00:00:21,730 --> 00:00:23,314
You know I bought your company.

12
00:00:23,398 --> 00:00:24,733
I bought your invention.

13
00:00:24,816 --> 00:00:26,818
How'd you like to finish what you started?

14
00:00:26,901 --> 00:00:29,446
He said: "Do it in Phoenix."

15
00:00:29,529 --> 00:00:32,281
"Find some space, hire some people."

16
00:00:32,365 --> 00:00:34,451
"Make me some money."

17
00:00:34,534 --> 00:00:36,536
(delightful squealing)

18
00:00:39,956 --> 00:00:42,959
♪ ♪

19
00:00:46,713 --> 00:00:49,924
ANNOUNCER: Tonight, on  Ripley's Believe It Or Not...

20
00:00:50,008 --> 00:00:51,968
you'll meet a hungry young woman

21
00:00:52,051 --> 00:00:55,638
with an appetite for cold steel...

22
00:00:55,722 --> 00:00:58,975
a music lover who has turned his very extremities

23
00:00:59,058 --> 00:01:01,102
into a sonorous instrument...

24
00:01:01,186 --> 00:01:04,813
(tooting "Yankee Doodle Dandy")

25
00:01:04,897 --> 00:01:08,276
...a contortionist who's perfected a method

26
00:01:08,359 --> 00:01:11,654
for examining his own spine...

27
00:01:11,738 --> 00:01:15,241
But first, in 1848,

28
00:01:15,325 --> 00:01:17,327
Phineas Gage was part of a work gang

29
00:01:17,410 --> 00:01:19,829
blasting rock while clearing the roadbed

30
00:01:19,913 --> 00:01:21,831
for a new railroad line.

31
00:01:21,915 --> 00:01:24,626
On September 13 of that year,

32
00:01:24,709 --> 00:01:27,587
Phineas's life would be changed forever

33
00:01:27,670 --> 00:01:29,339
by one simple spark.

34
00:01:29,422 --> 00:01:32,008
He was tamping down an explosive charge

35
00:01:32,091 --> 00:01:32,967
with an iron rod

36
00:01:33,051 --> 00:01:35,512
when the gunpowder ignited early

37
00:01:35,595 --> 00:01:37,680
and a three-foot iron rod

38
00:01:37,764 --> 00:01:40,475
was blown clear through Phineas's skull.

39
00:01:40,558 --> 00:01:43,436
Miraculously, Phineas survive.

40
00:01:46,231 --> 00:01:50,235
His body, it seemed, had made a complete recovery.

41
00:01:50,318 --> 00:01:53,363
His spirit, on the other hand...

42
00:01:57,325 --> 00:01:59,577
Those who knew Phineas best

43
00:01:59,661 --> 00:02:02,872
said he was a changed man after his accident.

44
00:02:02,956 --> 00:02:05,416
Once even-keeled and hardworking,

45
00:02:05,500 --> 00:02:09,086
he was now fitful, irreverent and grossly profane.

46
00:02:09,169 --> 00:02:11,506
But would it surprise you to learn

47
00:02:11,589 --> 00:02:14,259
that Phineas, after a long night of drinking,

48
00:02:14,342 --> 00:02:17,428
once identified himself to a fellow inebriate

49
00:02:17,512 --> 00:02:19,430
as "Cyrus Ames"?

50
00:02:19,514 --> 00:02:23,184
Who, you ask, was Cyrus Ames?

51
00:02:23,268 --> 00:02:26,938
Cyrus Ames was a notorious gunfighter and card cheat.

52
00:02:27,021 --> 00:02:29,899
For a time, he was employed by the railroads

53
00:02:29,983 --> 00:02:31,860
to shoot any Indians who attempted to interfere

54
00:02:31,943 --> 00:02:33,653
with the construction.

55
00:02:33,736 --> 00:02:36,239
On the day of Phineas's accident,

56
00:02:36,322 --> 00:02:40,243
Cyrus Ames lay dying of syphilis in the very same

57
00:02:40,326 --> 00:02:42,829
doctor's office where Phineas was treated.

58
00:02:42,912 --> 00:02:44,080
There are some who believe

59
00:02:44,163 --> 00:02:47,876
that an exchange of sorts took place that day.

60
00:02:47,959 --> 00:02:50,253
That the soul of a dying gunfighter

61
00:02:50,336 --> 00:02:55,758
somehow slipped into the body of an injured railroad worker.

62
00:02:55,842 --> 00:02:57,635
Coincidence? We may never know.

63
00:02:57,719 --> 00:03:00,597
Unlikely? Yes.

64
00:03:00,680 --> 00:03:04,267
Impossible? You be the judge.

65
00:03:04,350 --> 00:03:06,978
A man by the name of Robert L. Ripley, after all,

66
00:03:07,061 --> 00:03:10,106
would challenge you to Believe it or Not!

67
00:03:10,189 --> 00:03:13,109
(ominous music plays)

68
00:03:14,152 --> 00:03:15,236
(gasps)

69
00:03:15,320 --> 00:03:17,238
Bad dream?

70
00:03:17,322 --> 00:03:19,240
Bad rerun.

71
00:03:19,324 --> 00:03:23,411
It was weird; I dreamt about an old TV show.

72
00:03:23,494 --> 00:03:27,498
Hmm? You mean no one's in danger?

73
00:03:27,582 --> 00:03:29,292
You don't have to call anyone?

74
00:03:29,375 --> 00:03:31,294
We can just go back to sleep?

75
00:03:31,377 --> 00:03:32,962
(sighs contentedly)

76
00:03:33,046 --> 00:03:35,006
Oh, I don't believe it.

77
00:04:23,054 --> 00:04:24,055
(elevator bell dings)

78
00:05:07,348 --> 00:05:08,891
Allison, you're here. Good.

79
00:05:08,975 --> 00:05:10,893
Once you're settled, would you join me and Lee

80
00:05:10,977 --> 00:05:12,603
for a meeting in the conference room, please?

81
00:05:12,687 --> 00:05:14,272
With him?

82
00:05:15,773 --> 00:05:17,775
With them.

83
00:05:19,152 --> 00:05:21,404
Lee, Allison, this is Joel Tiernan.

84
00:05:21,487 --> 00:05:25,033
And sitting beside him is my old friend, his wife, Gabrielle.

85
00:05:25,116 --> 00:05:27,243
Six months ago,

86
00:05:27,326 --> 00:05:29,203
Gabrielle's sister, Robin, was found murdered

87
00:05:29,287 --> 00:05:31,748
in a cottage she'd rented on Saguaro Lake.

88
00:05:31,831 --> 00:05:34,083
There were no witnesses

89
00:05:34,167 --> 00:05:35,418
and as of now,

90
00:05:35,501 --> 00:05:37,253
no suspects.

91
00:05:37,336 --> 00:05:39,213
This all took place during the time

92
00:05:39,297 --> 00:05:41,799
when District Attorney Van Dyke was running this office.

93
00:05:41,883 --> 00:05:45,219
His people worked the case but, uh, but never solved it.

94
00:05:45,303 --> 00:05:50,266
I believe it was, um, August 16

95
00:05:50,349 --> 00:05:51,934
when I first realized that

96
00:05:52,018 --> 00:05:55,104
the Phoenix Police Department had given up on trying to find

97
00:05:55,188 --> 00:05:57,482
my sister's killer. I had, uh...

98
00:05:57,565 --> 00:06:00,151
I had called District Attorney Van Dyke for an update,

99
00:06:00,234 --> 00:06:04,822
and, um, he told me there were no new developments in the case.

100
00:06:04,906 --> 00:06:08,743
When I asked him when I might expect any new developments,

101
00:06:08,826 --> 00:06:10,953
he was kind enough to explain to me

102
00:06:11,037 --> 00:06:13,831
that good police work depends on good leads

103
00:06:13,915 --> 00:06:17,460
and since there were no new leads in the case...

104
00:06:17,543 --> 00:06:20,296
DEVALOS: Six months ago,

105
00:06:20,379 --> 00:06:22,131
there was nothing I could do about that.

106
00:06:22,215 --> 00:06:24,967
Now I can.

107
00:06:25,051 --> 00:06:28,387
That's why I'm putting my two best people on it.

108
00:06:30,723 --> 00:06:33,976
ROBIN: I'm going to tell her everything.

109
00:06:34,060 --> 00:06:35,895
What did you just say?

110
00:06:35,978 --> 00:06:38,439
You heard me.

111
00:06:38,523 --> 00:06:42,485
I'm going to tell her everything.

112
00:06:47,532 --> 00:06:48,741
(elevator bell dings)

113
00:06:52,078 --> 00:06:53,162
I think I saw his face.

114
00:06:53,246 --> 00:06:54,831
What are you talking about?

115
00:06:54,914 --> 00:06:57,166
The killer, I think I saw his face.

116
00:06:57,250 --> 00:06:59,919
Maybe if you put me together with a sketch artist,

117
00:07:00,002 --> 00:07:02,547
we might have something for you to work with this afternoon.

118
00:07:02,630 --> 00:07:04,215
(school bell rings)

119
00:07:04,298 --> 00:07:07,343
Hey, kiddo. How was school?

120
00:07:08,928 --> 00:07:10,721
Hmm?

121
00:07:10,805 --> 00:07:12,849
Why the long face?

122
00:07:12,932 --> 00:07:16,352
I sort of got in trouble in art class.

123
00:07:16,435 --> 00:07:18,354
Oh, yeah? What happened?

124
00:07:18,437 --> 00:07:23,693
I kind of drew a funny picture of my teacher, Mr. Enright.

125
00:07:23,776 --> 00:07:26,070
Uh-oh. Did you apologize?

126
00:07:26,154 --> 00:07:29,198
Well, yeah, but he wants you and Mom

127
00:07:29,282 --> 00:07:32,201
to look at the picture anyways and sign it

128
00:07:32,285 --> 00:07:35,329
so he knows you saw it. Okay.

129
00:07:41,627 --> 00:07:43,546
Bridgette, you drew this?

130
00:07:43,629 --> 00:07:45,548
That man is naked.

131
00:07:45,631 --> 00:07:47,925
He sure is.

132
00:07:48,009 --> 00:07:49,552
DEVALOS: This is the man you

133
00:07:49,635 --> 00:07:51,262
believe murdered Robin Aaronson?

134
00:07:51,345 --> 00:07:53,723
I think it's a pretty good likeness.

135
00:08:04,358 --> 00:08:07,445
Tell me, is this the man you saw?

136
00:08:08,779 --> 00:08:11,073
Yes. Absolutely.

137
00:08:11,157 --> 00:08:12,241
You know this man?

138
00:08:12,325 --> 00:08:13,826
I knew him.

139
00:08:13,910 --> 00:08:15,286
He was Gabrielle's first husband, Nathan.

140
00:08:15,369 --> 00:08:17,330
He was a very successful novelist,

141
00:08:17,413 --> 00:08:21,918
and when he died, he left Gabrielle a very wealthy woman.

142
00:08:22,001 --> 00:08:23,502
He's dead?

143
00:08:23,586 --> 00:08:25,504
He was killed in a car crash two years ago,

144
00:08:25,588 --> 00:08:27,256
driving home from a writers' retreat.

145
00:08:27,340 --> 00:08:29,967
Struck head-on by another vehicle, a stolen vehicle.

146
00:08:30,051 --> 00:08:32,886
And by the time the accident site was discovered,

147
00:08:32,970 --> 00:08:35,097
the other driver, the car thief, had disappeared.

148
00:08:35,181 --> 00:08:36,599
Skulked off into the night.

149
00:08:36,682 --> 00:08:39,602
We never managed to identify him.

150
00:08:39,684 --> 00:08:42,438
I'm sorry, Allison. I don't know what you think you saw,

151
00:08:42,520 --> 00:08:44,815
but Nathan's been dead for two years now.

152
00:08:44,899 --> 00:08:47,568
It seems unlikely that he killed Gabrielle's sister six months ago.

153
00:08:47,652 --> 00:08:49,445
(faucet running)

154
00:08:49,528 --> 00:08:51,113
JOE: Hey, look on the bright side.

155
00:08:51,197 --> 00:08:53,074
At least this woman wasn't in the room

156
00:08:53,157 --> 00:08:55,117
when you accused her dead husband of murdering her sister.

157
00:08:55,201 --> 00:08:58,162
Would you put that thing away already?

158
00:08:58,246 --> 00:09:00,498
I'm sorry. It's just so...

159
00:09:00,581 --> 00:09:03,459
(laughing): Accurate?

160
00:09:03,543 --> 00:09:07,004
Yeah, I mean I know we've had the talk with Bridgette,

161
00:09:07,088 --> 00:09:09,340
and I know she's seen all this stuff in science class,

162
00:09:09,423 --> 00:09:10,841
but I mean, it's just...

163
00:09:10,925 --> 00:09:12,176
But what?

164
00:09:12,260 --> 00:09:13,135
You're acting like you never

165
00:09:13,219 --> 00:09:15,763
drew a picture of a naked person before.

166
00:09:15,846 --> 00:09:17,473
Yeah, I'm sure that I scribbled

167
00:09:17,557 --> 00:09:19,308
the occasional "bazoom" in my notebook,

168
00:09:19,392 --> 00:09:20,518
but I mean, nothing like this.

169
00:09:22,395 --> 00:09:25,356
What? A young boy's fascination with "bazooms" is okay?

170
00:09:25,439 --> 00:09:27,984
But a young girl's curiosity about that isn't?

171
00:09:28,067 --> 00:09:30,945
I'm just going to turn off the light now.

172
00:09:31,028 --> 00:09:32,697
Yeah, you do that.

173
00:09:39,912 --> 00:09:41,998
♪ ♪

174
00:09:46,210 --> 00:09:48,212
(papers rustling)

175
00:09:54,093 --> 00:09:56,137
(exhaust hissing)

176
00:10:04,270 --> 00:10:05,479
(door creaks open)

177
00:10:14,447 --> 00:10:15,906
(gasps)

178
00:10:21,287 --> 00:10:23,497
SCANLON: So, you're telling me Joel Tiernan did this?

179
00:10:23,581 --> 00:10:26,876
Joel Tiernan, Gabrielle Tiernan's current husband,

180
00:10:26,959 --> 00:10:27,877
is, in fact, the hit-and-run driver

181
00:10:27,960 --> 00:10:30,296
who killed her first husband, Nathan Cafferty?

182
00:10:32,798 --> 00:10:35,343
That is one very forgiving lady.

183
00:10:35,426 --> 00:10:37,261
Well, obviously, I don't think she knows.

184
00:10:37,345 --> 00:10:39,388
Obviously.

185
00:10:39,472 --> 00:10:41,015
Look, I know how this sounds, Lee,

186
00:10:41,098 --> 00:10:43,184
but I dreamt about it last night.

187
00:10:43,267 --> 00:10:46,187
Joel Tiernan was the other driver in that accident.

188
00:10:46,270 --> 00:10:48,898
And I think that's how he got that big scar on his forehead.

189
00:10:49,982 --> 00:10:51,400
What?!

190
00:10:51,484 --> 00:10:53,402
I'm sorry, it's just Manny puts us on one cold case,

191
00:10:53,486 --> 00:10:56,238
and you start dreaming about another that's even colder.

192
00:10:56,322 --> 00:10:58,282
Maybe tonight you'll see who took the Lindbergh baby.

193
00:10:58,366 --> 00:10:59,241
What if I'm right?

194
00:10:59,325 --> 00:11:02,495
What if Joel Tiernan is responsible for this?

195
00:11:03,871 --> 00:11:05,790
If you're sure about what you saw,

196
00:11:05,873 --> 00:11:07,750
and when I say "sure," I'm talking

197
00:11:07,833 --> 00:11:10,878
in the neighborhood of 100 percent...

198
00:11:10,961 --> 00:11:12,630
then I'll bring the guy in for questioning,

199
00:11:12,713 --> 00:11:14,256
ask him to account for his whereabouts

200
00:11:14,340 --> 00:11:16,926
at the time of the wreck, but if you're not...

201
00:11:17,009 --> 00:11:18,761
Remember, these are Manny's friends.

202
00:11:18,844 --> 00:11:20,930
At least the wife is.

203
00:11:21,013 --> 00:11:22,598
I got to tell you, if you're right

204
00:11:22,681 --> 00:11:24,433
about this Tiernan guy, Gabrielle sure can pick them.

205
00:11:24,517 --> 00:11:26,602
What is that supposed to mean?

206
00:11:26,685 --> 00:11:27,603
I interviewed a few of the

207
00:11:27,686 --> 00:11:29,814
dead sister's friends yesterday.

208
00:11:29,897 --> 00:11:31,315
One of them told me about a little accident

209
00:11:31,399 --> 00:11:32,566
Robin had in '06.

210
00:11:32,650 --> 00:11:33,734
She claimed she'd fallen,

211
00:11:33,818 --> 00:11:36,278
but the friend spotted some, uh, bruising around her neck.

212
00:11:36,362 --> 00:11:39,448
Got the feeling she may have been covering for someone.

213
00:11:39,532 --> 00:11:42,243
An abusive boyfriend, maybe.

214
00:11:42,326 --> 00:11:44,829
Turns out she was.

215
00:11:44,912 --> 00:11:47,915
And his name was Nathan Cafferty.

216
00:11:47,998 --> 00:11:51,210
Wait a second, she was having an affair

217
00:11:51,293 --> 00:11:52,294
with her sister's husband?

218
00:11:52,378 --> 00:11:54,296
For about a year until Nathan decided

219
00:11:54,380 --> 00:11:56,507
he was still in love with Gabrielle.

220
00:11:56,590 --> 00:11:58,801
According to the friend, Robin didn't take it well.

221
00:11:58,884 --> 00:12:00,761
Threatened to tell her sister.

222
00:12:00,845 --> 00:12:02,930
Nathan got physical.

223
00:12:03,013 --> 00:12:05,391
Grabbed Robin by the neck, threw her up against the wall.

224
00:12:08,394 --> 00:12:11,313
It happened in the same cabin she died in.

225
00:12:11,397 --> 00:12:13,524
I saw it, Lee. I saw it yesterday.

226
00:12:13,607 --> 00:12:16,819
I just didn't understand. So, so, wait...

227
00:12:16,902 --> 00:12:19,321
So, if Robin was having an affair with Nathan,

228
00:12:19,405 --> 00:12:21,115
shouldn't we bring in Gabrielle for questioning?

229
00:12:21,198 --> 00:12:22,366
She's the one with the motive.

230
00:12:22,450 --> 00:12:24,952
If she knew her sister was getting it on with her husband, sure.

231
00:12:25,035 --> 00:12:27,663
But, uh, according to the friend, she never found out.

232
00:12:27,746 --> 00:12:29,373
Besides, I did some checking.

233
00:12:29,457 --> 00:12:32,126
There are all kinds of photos of her at some charity event

234
00:12:32,209 --> 00:12:34,545
in Flagstaff till the wee hours on the night of the murder.

235
00:12:34,628 --> 00:12:37,923
Plus, she's the one who came to us for help, remember?

236
00:12:38,007 --> 00:12:41,177
It wouldn't make much sense to reheat a case that'd gone cold

237
00:12:41,260 --> 00:12:44,013
if, uh, if you were the killer, now, would it?

238
00:12:44,096 --> 00:12:45,806
JOE: Hey, it's me.

239
00:12:45,890 --> 00:12:48,350
Um, hey, listen. Uh, I just got a call from Bridgette's school.

240
00:12:48,434 --> 00:12:50,186
They want us to come in today at 3:00

241
00:12:50,269 --> 00:12:51,395
to meet with, uh,

242
00:12:51,479 --> 00:12:53,689
her art teacher and a school counselor.

243
00:12:53,772 --> 00:12:55,024
(sighs): Okay.

244
00:12:55,107 --> 00:12:57,193
I teach art, Mr. and Mrs. Dubois.

245
00:12:57,276 --> 00:12:59,695
I'm not a prudish man, and if I were teaching

246
00:12:59,778 --> 00:13:02,573
a life drawing class to a group of college students,

247
00:13:02,656 --> 00:13:04,533
I might be inclined to laugh this off, but

248
00:13:04,617 --> 00:13:06,076
the fact is,

249
00:13:06,160 --> 00:13:09,205
Bridgette is a ten-year-old in a fourth-grade art class.

250
00:13:09,288 --> 00:13:12,708
And this is the second time in two days she's drawn

251
00:13:12,791 --> 00:13:15,836
a vivid portrait of me-- her teacher.

252
00:13:15,920 --> 00:13:17,379
I don't know what to say, Mr. Enright.

253
00:13:17,463 --> 00:13:20,799
This obviously is inappropriate,

254
00:13:20,883 --> 00:13:22,092
and we're very sorry. Yeah.

255
00:13:22,176 --> 00:13:24,178
I appreciate that. And please understand,

256
00:13:24,261 --> 00:13:26,555
Bridgette is one of the most imaginative students I've ever had

257
00:13:26,639 --> 00:13:29,517
the pleasure to teach. I adore having her in the class,

258
00:13:29,600 --> 00:13:32,686
but I'd be lying if I said the last couple of days

259
00:13:32,770 --> 00:13:34,355
haven't been disturbing to me.

260
00:13:34,438 --> 00:13:37,775
So, that's why I asked Mrs. Tharp to sit in with us.

261
00:13:37,858 --> 00:13:40,528
Mr. Enright and I thought that perhaps Bridgette

262
00:13:40,611 --> 00:13:43,280
could use the benefit of a few sessions with me.

263
00:13:43,364 --> 00:13:46,283
You think that Bridgette needs to see a psychologist?

264
00:13:46,367 --> 00:13:47,743
Because of this?

265
00:13:47,826 --> 00:13:49,370
MRS. THARP: The drawings are rather graphic.

266
00:13:49,453 --> 00:13:51,205
We just wanted to find out

267
00:13:51,288 --> 00:13:53,457
where Bridgette got the impulse to make them.

268
00:13:53,541 --> 00:13:55,960
To see if she's been exposed to anything that could have

269
00:13:56,043 --> 00:13:59,797
caused this preoccupation with the naked form.

270
00:13:59,880 --> 00:14:02,716
Oh, wait a second. She hasn't been exposed to anything,

271
00:14:02,800 --> 00:14:04,301
and this is not a preoccupation.

272
00:14:04,385 --> 00:14:07,137
It's just a kid just using her imagination.

273
00:14:07,221 --> 00:14:09,265
I mean, Bridgette needs a lesson

274
00:14:09,348 --> 00:14:10,307
in what's appropriate and what-what isn't.

275
00:14:10,391 --> 00:14:12,726
She doesn't need, she doesn't need to go to therapy.

276
00:14:12,810 --> 00:14:15,229
With all due respect, you're not the subject

277
00:14:15,312 --> 00:14:17,189
of the drawings, Mr. Dubois. I am.

278
00:14:17,273 --> 00:14:18,023
Okay, but... And I'm not

279
00:14:18,107 --> 00:14:19,608
sure I agree with your assessment.

280
00:14:19,692 --> 00:14:21,068
Well, I'm not sure that you know my daughter

281
00:14:21,151 --> 00:14:22,736
as well as you think you do, Mr. Enright.

282
00:14:22,820 --> 00:14:23,862
Uh... Mrs. Tharp,

283
00:14:23,946 --> 00:14:26,615
we do appreciate your offer, I think

284
00:14:26,699 --> 00:14:28,117
we're going to speak with Bridgette ourselves

285
00:14:28,200 --> 00:14:30,786
before we take you up on that.

286
00:14:30,869 --> 00:14:35,291
Mr. Enright, I am sorry for any kind of discomfort

287
00:14:35,374 --> 00:14:38,252
or embarrassment that our daughter may have caused you.

288
00:14:38,335 --> 00:14:40,921
We will make sure we speak with Bridgette and let her know

289
00:14:41,005 --> 00:14:44,300
that these kinds of drawings in school are not appropriate.

290
00:14:44,383 --> 00:14:46,135
Absolutely.

291
00:14:46,218 --> 00:14:50,139
And I promise you this will never happen again.

292
00:14:55,561 --> 00:14:57,479
Hi, kiddo. How you doing?

293
00:14:57,563 --> 00:14:59,940
Okay.

294
00:15:00,024 --> 00:15:01,317
I'm sorry.

295
00:15:01,400 --> 00:15:04,486
Hey, it's okay, sweetie. We're not mad at you.

296
00:15:04,570 --> 00:15:07,156
But you need to stop drawing pictures of your teacher.

297
00:15:07,239 --> 00:15:08,991
It's making him uncomfortable.

298
00:15:09,074 --> 00:15:12,953
Well, I didn't  want  to draw another picture of Mr. Enright.

299
00:15:13,037 --> 00:15:15,289
I just felt like I had to.

300
00:15:15,372 --> 00:15:17,124
What do you mean, you had to?

301
00:15:17,207 --> 00:15:18,834
I don't know.

302
00:15:18,917 --> 00:15:22,671
When I close my eyes, I see him in my head.

303
00:15:22,755 --> 00:15:27,635
And I just know that I have to put it down on paper.

304
00:15:27,718 --> 00:15:28,969
JOE: Maybe Bridgette's not

305
00:15:29,053 --> 00:15:30,304
the problem here. Maybe... maybe

306
00:15:30,387 --> 00:15:32,181
it's that teacher that we should be worried about.

307
00:15:32,264 --> 00:15:34,183
So, what are you saying? This is Mr. Enright's fault?

308
00:15:34,266 --> 00:15:36,143
Well, I don't know. All I'm... All I know is that

309
00:15:36,226 --> 00:15:37,978
she goes in his class, and then she feels like

310
00:15:38,062 --> 00:15:40,064
she has to draw him without his clothes on.

311
00:15:40,147 --> 00:15:42,149
Why? Huh? What's going on in this guy's head?

312
00:15:42,232 --> 00:15:43,359
What kind of, I don't know,

313
00:15:43,442 --> 00:15:45,235
energy is Bridgette picking up on?

314
00:15:45,319 --> 00:15:46,362
What are you saying?

315
00:15:46,445 --> 00:15:48,656
Mr. Enright's putting in some kind of "naked energy"?

316
00:15:48,739 --> 00:15:50,240
I don't know, but I think that we should talk

317
00:15:50,324 --> 00:15:51,867
to somebody at the school, and we should get her

318
00:15:51,950 --> 00:15:53,577
transferred to another class. Whoa!

319
00:15:53,661 --> 00:15:55,704
Okay, good luck with that conversation.

320
00:15:55,788 --> 00:15:57,873
You'd better make sure that you have your facts straight.

321
00:15:57,956 --> 00:15:59,208
If you're going to accuse somebody

322
00:15:59,291 --> 00:16:01,210
of putting out a "naked vibe,"

323
00:16:01,293 --> 00:16:03,462
just make sure you have all your ducks in a row.

324
00:16:03,545 --> 00:16:05,547
I don't understand how you can just dismiss this.

325
00:16:05,631 --> 00:16:07,883
I'm not. It'll pass, Joe.

326
00:16:07,966 --> 00:16:09,927
I asked Bridgette specifically,

327
00:16:10,010 --> 00:16:10,928
"Did anything

328
00:16:11,011 --> 00:16:12,054
inappropriate happen?"

329
00:16:12,137 --> 00:16:14,223
"Anything at all that made you feel uncomfortable?"

330
00:16:14,306 --> 00:16:16,225
She said no. It'll pass.

331
00:16:16,308 --> 00:16:19,687
Whatever it is that's making her want to draw these pictures,

332
00:16:19,770 --> 00:16:21,355
it'll pass.

333
00:16:21,438 --> 00:16:22,940
(phone ringing) If we make a huge thing

334
00:16:23,023 --> 00:16:24,942
of this, we're just going to make Bridgette

335
00:16:25,025 --> 00:16:26,860
more confused than she already is.

336
00:16:26,944 --> 00:16:27,820
(phone ringing)

337
00:16:27,903 --> 00:16:28,779
Hello?

338
00:16:28,862 --> 00:16:30,072
All right, you got me thinking.

339
00:16:30,155 --> 00:16:33,784
I just took a look at our files on Nathan Cafferty's accident.

340
00:16:33,867 --> 00:16:35,577
Unfortunately, it turns out the city destroyed both cars

341
00:16:35,661 --> 00:16:37,121
about a year ago. (whispers): It's Scanlon.

342
00:16:37,204 --> 00:16:38,747
It's not like we're going to find any DNA

343
00:16:38,831 --> 00:16:41,583
to help us figure out who was driving that other car.

344
00:16:41,667 --> 00:16:44,503
But I did find one interesting thing.

345
00:16:44,586 --> 00:16:46,755
Turns out our friend Joel has a record.

346
00:16:46,839 --> 00:16:48,257
Arrested in '02 for car theft,

347
00:16:48,340 --> 00:16:50,217
and again in '04 for check-kiting.

348
00:16:50,300 --> 00:16:52,052
Although how that proves he killed Nathan Cafferty,

349
00:16:52,136 --> 00:16:53,095
I have no idea.

350
00:16:53,178 --> 00:16:54,430
Well, what about the papers?

351
00:16:54,513 --> 00:16:56,223
Maybe you should check the papers.

352
00:16:56,306 --> 00:16:57,933
What papers?

353
00:16:58,016 --> 00:17:00,936
The papers from the accident scene. They were everywhere.

354
00:17:01,019 --> 00:17:03,480
There were hundreds of them. I saw Joel touch one of them.

355
00:17:03,564 --> 00:17:04,982
If they're in the evidence locker,

356
00:17:05,065 --> 00:17:06,900
maybe we should check them for fingerprints.

357
00:17:06,983 --> 00:17:08,777
Allison, I'm looking at the report right here,

358
00:17:08,861 --> 00:17:10,112
and there's no mention of any papers.

359
00:17:10,194 --> 00:17:12,406
Just two cars and one dead body.

360
00:17:12,489 --> 00:17:14,116
You know what I think your problem is?

361
00:17:14,199 --> 00:17:15,659
You're focusing on the wrong case.

362
00:17:15,742 --> 00:17:17,953
Our boss asks us to help solve the murder

363
00:17:18,037 --> 00:17:19,788
of his friend's sister, and instead, you're running around

364
00:17:19,872 --> 00:17:20,914
trying to prove that her husband

365
00:17:20,998 --> 00:17:22,458
committed vehicular manslaughter.

366
00:17:22,540 --> 00:17:24,251
Maybe you should just stick to the case at hand.

367
00:17:24,334 --> 00:17:26,627
Just a suggestion.

368
00:17:26,712 --> 00:17:29,757
Tell me about the first time we made love.

369
00:17:29,840 --> 00:17:32,760
We were staying at your parents' house.

370
00:17:32,843 --> 00:17:36,180
MAN: You snuck into the guest room to join me.

371
00:17:36,263 --> 00:17:39,266
You were worried about getting caught.

372
00:17:39,349 --> 00:17:42,644
But then you fell asleep in my arms.

373
00:17:42,728 --> 00:17:44,646
Your mom woke us up in the morning.

374
00:17:44,730 --> 00:17:47,941
(chuckles): But she didn't seem that mad.

375
00:17:53,697 --> 00:17:56,992
How did we celebrate when you sold your first novel?

376
00:17:57,076 --> 00:17:58,744
We booked a presidential suite

377
00:17:58,827 --> 00:18:01,163
at a resort we couldn't afford,

378
00:18:01,246 --> 00:18:04,291
and we ordered room service all weekend.

379
00:18:08,754 --> 00:18:11,131
I was, uh...

380
00:18:11,215 --> 00:18:13,175
I had a difficult year.

381
00:18:13,258 --> 00:18:15,177
I was, I was going through something.

382
00:18:15,260 --> 00:18:17,721
The miscarriage.

383
00:18:17,805 --> 00:18:20,307
You were almost three months along.

384
00:18:20,390 --> 00:18:22,017
No one knew but us.

385
00:18:22,100 --> 00:18:25,979
And we were just about to share the good news with our parents.

386
00:18:26,063 --> 00:18:28,482
We even had names picked out.

387
00:18:28,565 --> 00:18:31,860
Courtney, if it was a girl.

388
00:18:31,944 --> 00:18:34,655
Peter, if it was a boy.

389
00:18:35,948 --> 00:18:37,741
(sobs)

390
00:18:37,825 --> 00:18:38,784
When you

391
00:18:38,867 --> 00:18:42,037
called me, I just...

392
00:18:42,120 --> 00:18:43,539
I just couldn't believe

393
00:18:43,622 --> 00:18:47,501
that anything you were saying could be true,

394
00:18:47,584 --> 00:18:49,503
that there was any chance that you could be

395
00:18:49,586 --> 00:18:52,756
who you said you were, that there was any

396
00:18:52,840 --> 00:18:56,552
possibility that... that we could be together again...

397
00:18:56,635 --> 00:18:58,011
It's me, Gabby.

398
00:18:58,095 --> 00:19:00,347
It's Nathan.

399
00:19:00,430 --> 00:19:02,891
And I've come back to you and I promise,

400
00:19:02,975 --> 00:19:04,768
I'm never going to leave you again.

401
00:19:14,403 --> 00:19:15,737
Mrs. Dubois.

402
00:19:15,821 --> 00:19:16,905
Hi, I'm sorry. I know it's early,

403
00:19:16,989 --> 00:19:18,282
I know I didn't call first.

404
00:19:18,365 --> 00:19:19,575
No, no, it's fine.

405
00:19:19,658 --> 00:19:22,035
What's, uh, what's on your mind?

406
00:19:22,119 --> 00:19:24,454
The night before I met you,

407
00:19:24,538 --> 00:19:28,458
I-I had a dream that, that I couldn't understand.

408
00:19:28,542 --> 00:19:31,670
It was about a man who died a long time ago.

409
00:19:31,753 --> 00:19:33,797
Only instead of his soul crossing over,

410
00:19:33,881 --> 00:19:37,509
it... it made its way into this other man.

411
00:19:40,804 --> 00:19:43,640
Well, I guess that's why I'm here.

412
00:19:43,724 --> 00:19:46,602
The more I come to learn about your family,

413
00:19:46,685 --> 00:19:50,314
the more sense this dream starts to make.

414
00:19:50,397 --> 00:19:53,817
After Nathan's accident, there were days

415
00:19:53,901 --> 00:19:55,611
I didn't know how I'd carry on,

416
00:19:55,694 --> 00:19:58,280
or if I even could carry on.

417
00:19:58,363 --> 00:20:01,700
But then, just when I was ready to give up...

418
00:20:01,783 --> 00:20:04,119
Joel Tiernan appeared?

419
00:20:04,202 --> 00:20:07,164
Imagine losing the love of your life,

420
00:20:07,247 --> 00:20:09,458
but then before you'd even begun

421
00:20:09,541 --> 00:20:11,668
to start mourning the loss, getting him back.

422
00:20:11,752 --> 00:20:13,795
Being spared the lifetime it would've taken

423
00:20:13,879 --> 00:20:15,631
to get over that loss.

424
00:20:15,714 --> 00:20:19,509
It was, uh, it was a miracle.

425
00:20:19,593 --> 00:20:21,720
Nothing short of a miracle.

426
00:20:21,803 --> 00:20:23,972
Surely you, of all people, can appreciate that.

427
00:20:24,056 --> 00:20:25,974
Did Nathan ever talk to you

428
00:20:26,058 --> 00:20:28,936
about what happened the night of the accident?

429
00:20:29,019 --> 00:20:30,312
Did he ever tell you how exactly

430
00:20:30,395 --> 00:20:32,648
he might have crossed paths with Joel Tiernan?

431
00:20:32,731 --> 00:20:37,194
No, no. All he remembered was the screeching of tires.

432
00:20:37,277 --> 00:20:38,862
Nothing after that.

433
00:20:38,946 --> 00:20:40,989
And in regards to Joel Tiernan,

434
00:20:41,073 --> 00:20:43,617
neither one of us remembered ever meeting him.

435
00:20:43,700 --> 00:20:46,787
We tried to investigate his life after the switch,

436
00:20:46,870 --> 00:20:48,288
but as it turned out,

437
00:20:48,372 --> 00:20:50,624
there wasn't much of a life to investigate.

438
00:20:50,707 --> 00:20:52,167
No family,

439
00:20:52,250 --> 00:20:55,963
no friends to notice Joel behaving differently.

440
00:20:56,046 --> 00:20:58,507
I can only imagine what a comfort it must've been

441
00:20:58,590 --> 00:21:00,300
to have your husband, your real husband,

442
00:21:00,384 --> 00:21:04,137
by your side when you got the news of Robin's death.

443
00:21:04,221 --> 00:21:07,349
Actually, I was, uh, I was by myself when I got the news.

444
00:21:07,432 --> 00:21:09,142
I'd gone to an event that night.

445
00:21:09,226 --> 00:21:10,185
Joel couldn't go

446
00:21:10,269 --> 00:21:14,856
and so we didn't see each other until much later...

447
00:21:14,940 --> 00:21:17,859
but it-it was, it was difficult for Joel, too.

448
00:21:17,943 --> 00:21:20,529
I think he loved her as much as I did.

449
00:21:22,155 --> 00:21:24,408
Bridge! I heard a rumor you weren't dressed yet.

450
00:21:24,491 --> 00:21:26,243
BRIDGETTE (crying): Leave me alone!

451
00:21:26,326 --> 00:21:27,661
Come on, come on.

452
00:21:27,744 --> 00:21:29,204
It's getting late.

453
00:21:29,288 --> 00:21:31,873
(sobbing): I'm sorry, Daddy.

454
00:21:31,957 --> 00:21:34,209
What are you sorry about, honey?

455
00:21:34,292 --> 00:21:35,252
What's the matter?

456
00:21:35,335 --> 00:21:39,214
I know I wasn't supposed to...

457
00:21:39,298 --> 00:21:41,842
but I couldn't stop.

458
00:21:41,925 --> 00:21:47,180
(sobbing)

459
00:21:49,599 --> 00:21:50,726
DEVALOS: Joel Tiernan

460
00:21:50,809 --> 00:21:52,102
is  Nathan Cafferty.

461
00:21:52,185 --> 00:21:53,562
That's what you're telling me?

462
00:21:53,645 --> 00:21:55,355
I know how this sounds.

463
00:21:55,439 --> 00:21:56,606
No, I don't think you do.

464
00:21:56,690 --> 00:21:58,066
It sounds insane, Allison.

465
00:21:58,150 --> 00:22:00,068
You are telling me that the essence

466
00:22:00,152 --> 00:22:02,070
of my friend's dead husband somehow

467
00:22:02,154 --> 00:22:04,906
found its way into the body of that man, Joel Tiernan,

468
00:22:04,990 --> 00:22:07,200
and that therefore, we should question Joel Tiernan

469
00:22:07,284 --> 00:22:09,077
for the, for the murder of Gabrielle's sister...?

470
00:22:09,161 --> 00:22:11,246
They were having an affair. She threatened to tell.

471
00:22:11,329 --> 00:22:12,456
Who was she having an affair with?

472
00:22:12,539 --> 00:22:13,915
On whom was she threatening to tell?

473
00:22:13,999 --> 00:22:15,083
They're one and the same.

474
00:22:15,167 --> 00:22:16,084
Right, and I think that's

475
00:22:16,168 --> 00:22:17,210
a pretty tough sell to a jury.

476
00:22:17,294 --> 00:22:19,087
Sir, I am telling you,

477
00:22:19,171 --> 00:22:20,422
Joel Tiernan was driving the car

478
00:22:20,505 --> 00:22:23,091
that killed Nathan Cafferty that night.

479
00:22:23,175 --> 00:22:25,886
Joel and Nathan were within yards of each other

480
00:22:25,969 --> 00:22:27,429
when Nathan's soul left his body,

481
00:22:27,512 --> 00:22:29,765
but instead of going wherever it was supposed to go...

482
00:22:29,848 --> 00:22:31,767
It did what? It... just made its way

483
00:22:31,850 --> 00:22:33,602
to the nearest warm body and took up residence.

484
00:22:33,685 --> 00:22:34,936
Is that really what you think?

485
00:22:35,020 --> 00:22:37,105
I know that's what his wife thinks.

486
00:22:37,189 --> 00:22:39,274
(sighs)

487
00:22:40,400 --> 00:22:42,360
Sir, please, can't we just bring him in here

488
00:22:42,444 --> 00:22:46,448
and ask him where he was the night his sister-in-law died?

489
00:22:46,531 --> 00:22:47,908
What do you mean? No one asked him that?

490
00:22:47,991 --> 00:22:50,118
No one has asked him anything.

491
00:22:50,202 --> 00:22:52,412
No one thought it mattered.

492
00:22:54,498 --> 00:22:57,250
In the past 24 hours, a theory of evidence has emerged.

493
00:22:57,334 --> 00:23:00,504
It's unconventional, to be sure, but I was just curious

494
00:23:00,587 --> 00:23:03,298
as to whether you might have a point of view about it.

495
00:23:03,381 --> 00:23:05,967
Mrs. Tiernan, Gabrielle,

496
00:23:06,051 --> 00:23:08,261
recently spoke with Mrs. Dubois here and...

497
00:23:08,345 --> 00:23:11,139
shared some very interesting things

498
00:23:11,223 --> 00:23:15,394
about the nature of you and your wife's... mutual attraction.

499
00:23:19,189 --> 00:23:20,649
(laughs)

500
00:23:20,732 --> 00:23:22,275
My wife...

501
00:23:22,359 --> 00:23:24,653
My wife is very spiritual.

502
00:23:24,736 --> 00:23:26,488
Uh...

503
00:23:26,571 --> 00:23:30,283
She has some rather romantic ideas about life and death.

504
00:23:30,367 --> 00:23:31,493
(laughs)

505
00:23:31,576 --> 00:23:34,121
Yeah. I'm not sure she's... (clears throat)

506
00:23:34,204 --> 00:23:36,498
entirely over the loss of her first husband.

507
00:23:36,581 --> 00:23:38,166
I suppose, inevitably,

508
00:23:38,250 --> 00:23:41,128
appearance aside, uh... I have some things,

509
00:23:41,211 --> 00:23:43,130
some traits in common with Nathan,

510
00:23:43,213 --> 00:23:45,507
and I'm sure Gabrielle...

511
00:23:45,590 --> 00:23:47,801
interprets those similarities,

512
00:23:47,884 --> 00:23:49,803
well, with a...

513
00:23:49,886 --> 00:23:51,179
a romantic's heart,

514
00:23:51,263 --> 00:23:54,182
a romantic's sensibility.

515
00:23:54,266 --> 00:23:56,685
I hope you don't think too badly of her.

516
00:23:57,769 --> 00:23:59,604
It's one of the reasons I love her so.

517
00:24:03,150 --> 00:24:04,025
Anything else?

518
00:24:04,109 --> 00:24:05,402
ALLISON: There  is  one more thing.

519
00:24:05,485 --> 00:24:08,363
Do you happen to remember where you were

520
00:24:08,446 --> 00:24:10,699
the night that Robin was murdered?

521
00:24:10,782 --> 00:24:13,326
Of course. Um, at home.

522
00:24:13,410 --> 00:24:15,871
In bed, sick.

523
00:24:15,954 --> 00:24:17,747
Gabrielle had this, uh...

524
00:24:17,831 --> 00:24:19,875
charity thing, really wanted me to go with her

525
00:24:19,958 --> 00:24:21,251
and meet some of her friends,

526
00:24:21,334 --> 00:24:23,253
but I just couldn't get out of bed.

527
00:24:24,796 --> 00:24:26,173
Then she got that horrible news...

528
00:24:26,256 --> 00:24:29,426
and we weren't even together,

529
00:24:29,509 --> 00:24:32,095
and, I mean, we're always  together.

530
00:24:32,179 --> 00:24:33,221
Was anyone else

531
00:24:33,305 --> 00:24:35,515
home that night? A cook, a maid?

532
00:24:35,599 --> 00:24:38,268
(clears throat)

533
00:24:38,351 --> 00:24:40,020
Would that be a "no"?

534
00:24:40,103 --> 00:24:43,231
Yes, that's a "no."

535
00:24:43,315 --> 00:24:45,692
Are you heading where I think you're heading?

536
00:24:45,775 --> 00:24:47,194
I barely knew Robin.

537
00:24:47,277 --> 00:24:49,237
I had just barely married her sister.

538
00:24:49,321 --> 00:24:51,907
Why in the world would I want to do her any harm?

539
00:24:51,990 --> 00:24:54,201
On the morning after Robin was murdered,

540
00:24:54,284 --> 00:24:57,537
the police found a... a spot of blood

541
00:24:57,621 --> 00:24:59,247
at the crime scene that wasn't hers.

542
00:24:59,331 --> 00:25:00,248
Yes, I know.

543
00:25:00,332 --> 00:25:02,250
It was in all the papers. So?

544
00:25:02,334 --> 00:25:05,295
So we were wondering if you'd mind giving us a blood sample.

545
00:25:06,338 --> 00:25:07,255
It would enable us

546
00:25:07,339 --> 00:25:09,925
to rule you out, Mr. Tiernan.

547
00:25:10,008 --> 00:25:13,220
Actually, I'm embarrassed that this wasn't attended to earlier.

548
00:25:13,303 --> 00:25:14,054
It's a simple request

549
00:25:14,137 --> 00:25:16,431
and I would infer nothing from it

550
00:25:16,514 --> 00:25:17,891
other than it would allow us

551
00:25:17,974 --> 00:25:18,934
to do our due diligence, and...

552
00:25:19,017 --> 00:25:21,269
we could look your wife in the eye and tell her

553
00:25:21,353 --> 00:25:22,979
that we have left no stone unturned.

554
00:25:23,063 --> 00:25:25,440
So, Mr. Tiernan, can Detective Scanlon

555
00:25:25,523 --> 00:25:27,192
take you downstairs?

556
00:25:29,069 --> 00:25:31,238
Is that a "no"?

557
00:25:31,321 --> 00:25:33,114
Yes, that's a "no."

558
00:25:33,198 --> 00:25:34,574
I will not

559
00:25:34,658 --> 00:25:37,786
participate in this  farce.

560
00:25:37,869 --> 00:25:39,496
I will not have my privacy invaded

561
00:25:39,579 --> 00:25:41,790
so you people can grasp at straws,

562
00:25:41,873 --> 00:25:42,832
and most importantly,

563
00:25:42,916 --> 00:25:45,293
I will not put my wife through the embarrassment

564
00:25:45,377 --> 00:25:48,296
and the humiliation and the pain

565
00:25:48,380 --> 00:25:50,799
of knowing that her pleas for help in this matter

566
00:25:50,882 --> 00:25:52,968
have yielded nothing but the most...

567
00:25:53,051 --> 00:25:59,182
cynical and simple-minded ideas about who might be responsible

568
00:25:59,266 --> 00:26:00,433
for her sister's death.

569
00:26:04,980 --> 00:26:05,814
Is that all?

570
00:26:05,897 --> 00:26:06,648
You know, I  can

571
00:26:06,731 --> 00:26:08,149
compel you to give us that blood.

572
00:26:08,233 --> 00:26:10,151
Well, by all means,

573
00:26:10,235 --> 00:26:12,112
call the family lawyer.

574
00:26:12,195 --> 00:26:13,446
Gabrielle will give you the number.

575
00:26:13,530 --> 00:26:15,365
I'm leaving now.

576
00:26:20,370 --> 00:26:21,204
JOE: I let go

577
00:26:21,288 --> 00:26:23,164
of the contractor that we hired to, to, uh...

578
00:26:23,248 --> 00:26:24,666
I'm home! Anyone want Chinese?

579
00:26:24,749 --> 00:26:27,294
...build the floor model for trade shows.

580
00:26:27,377 --> 00:26:28,295
Okay, that sounds good.

581
00:26:28,378 --> 00:26:29,546
We'll take new bids in next week.

582
00:26:29,629 --> 00:26:31,131
I'll, I'll see you in the morning.

583
00:26:31,214 --> 00:26:32,507
Hi.

584
00:26:32,590 --> 00:26:33,383
You're back early.

585
00:26:33,466 --> 00:26:35,302
Actually, I worked from home today. Um...

586
00:26:35,385 --> 00:26:37,137
you were in meetings and I needed to make

587
00:26:37,220 --> 00:26:38,722
an executive parental decision,

588
00:26:38,805 --> 00:26:41,016
and after I made it, I didn't see the point

589
00:26:41,099 --> 00:26:42,350
in discussing it until you got home.

590
00:26:42,434 --> 00:26:44,185
Discussing what?

591
00:26:44,269 --> 00:26:46,187
JOE: She was upset. She was embarrassed, and I-I just couldn't

592
00:26:46,271 --> 00:26:47,689
bring myself to force her to go to school.

593
00:26:47,772 --> 00:26:48,940
What, you couldn't bring yourself?

594
00:26:49,024 --> 00:26:49,983
Well, you weren't here.

595
00:26:50,066 --> 00:26:51,526
You didn't see the look on her face.

596
00:26:51,609 --> 00:26:53,361
She just kept saying that she couldn't help herself.

597
00:26:53,445 --> 00:26:55,905
Now, I, I think we should just keep her away from school

598
00:26:55,989 --> 00:26:57,073
until this thing passes.

599
00:26:57,157 --> 00:26:58,366
You want her to miss more school?

600
00:26:58,450 --> 00:27:00,201
Yeah, as a matter of fact, I do.

601
00:27:00,285 --> 00:27:02,245
I mean, you know, p-p-people do it all the time.

602
00:27:02,329 --> 00:27:03,330
Kids get sick, they stay home.

603
00:27:03,413 --> 00:27:04,706
But she's not sick.

604
00:27:04,789 --> 00:27:06,541
She's not sick, Joe.

605
00:27:06,624 --> 00:27:08,376
This is happening for a reason.

606
00:27:08,460 --> 00:27:10,378
She's drawing these pictures for a reason.

607
00:27:10,462 --> 00:27:14,049
She can't just miss school 'cause we don't know what it is, I mean...

608
00:27:14,132 --> 00:27:16,259
What if we never figure it out?

609
00:27:18,303 --> 00:27:19,679
Wait a second. What is this?

610
00:27:19,763 --> 00:27:21,181
What's what?

611
00:27:21,264 --> 00:27:23,183
I don't know. This spot.

612
00:27:23,266 --> 00:27:25,894
On Mr. Enright's chest.

613
00:27:25,977 --> 00:27:28,396
I don't know. It's his, you know, his nipple.

614
00:27:28,480 --> 00:27:29,856
No, I don't think so.

615
00:27:29,939 --> 00:27:31,399
Look, there's only one.

616
00:27:33,151 --> 00:27:35,070
And look, it's on all these.

617
00:27:35,153 --> 00:27:36,905
She drew it on every single picture.

618
00:27:36,988 --> 00:27:38,031
Is it growing?

619
00:27:38,114 --> 00:27:39,908
ALLISON: It looks like it's just

620
00:27:39,991 --> 00:27:41,409
changing shape. Look, this one's like

621
00:27:41,493 --> 00:27:44,287
a little circle, and then here it's almost like an X.

622
00:27:47,165 --> 00:27:50,543
Maybe she's not just drawing  Mr. Enright.

623
00:27:50,627 --> 00:27:52,087
Maybe she's diagnosing him.

624
00:27:52,170 --> 00:27:53,254
REPORTER: The city of

625
00:27:53,338 --> 00:27:56,216
Phoenix mourned today, as one of its favorite sons,

626
00:27:56,299 --> 00:27:57,092
renowned author Nathan Cafferty,

627
00:27:57,175 --> 00:27:59,094
was laid to rest.

628
00:27:59,177 --> 00:28:02,097
Mr. Cafferty, whose net worth was estimated

629
00:28:02,180 --> 00:28:05,600
at somewhere between $15 and $20 million, was killed

630
00:28:05,683 --> 00:28:08,103
last week when his car was struck head-on

631
00:28:08,186 --> 00:28:09,187
by another vehicle.

632
00:28:09,270 --> 00:28:12,440
He is survived by his wife, Gabrielle, who insists

633
00:28:12,524 --> 00:28:14,943
that rumors that her husband was working on a new book

634
00:28:15,026 --> 00:28:16,486
at the time of his death were,

635
00:28:16,569 --> 00:28:19,239
to the best of  her knowledge, untrue.

636
00:28:30,041 --> 00:28:32,794
"Our friends often commented that we made an odd couple,

637
00:28:32,877 --> 00:28:34,504
"Gabrielle and I.

638
00:28:34,587 --> 00:28:36,381
"She believed with all her heart

639
00:28:36,464 --> 00:28:38,133
"that there was far more to this universe

640
00:28:38,216 --> 00:28:41,511
"than the so-called 'scientists' would have us believe.

641
00:28:41,594 --> 00:28:43,346
"I, of course, did not.

642
00:28:43,430 --> 00:28:45,390
"To the casual observer, it may have appeared

643
00:28:45,473 --> 00:28:47,475
"we had little in common, but faith,

644
00:28:47,559 --> 00:28:51,146
"as it has often been said, is feminine.

645
00:28:51,229 --> 00:28:53,314
"Even the cynic who believes in nothing

646
00:28:53,398 --> 00:28:57,610
can find a girl who believes in  him."

647
00:29:20,508 --> 00:29:22,051
I was wrong.

648
00:29:22,135 --> 00:29:23,845
Joel Tiernan isn't walking around

649
00:29:23,928 --> 00:29:25,889
with the soul of Nathan Cafferty inside of him.

650
00:29:25,972 --> 00:29:28,975
He's walking around with Nathan Cafferty's autobiography.

651
00:29:29,058 --> 00:29:29,976
I beg your pardon?

652
00:29:30,059 --> 00:29:31,186
Remember I told you

653
00:29:31,269 --> 00:29:33,188
that I saw pages raining down from the sky

654
00:29:33,271 --> 00:29:34,522
the night of the car wreck?

655
00:29:34,606 --> 00:29:35,857
I think that's what it was.

656
00:29:35,940 --> 00:29:38,818
It was Nathan Cafferty's autobiography.

657
00:29:38,902 --> 00:29:41,863
Joel stole it before anyone else could read it.

658
00:29:41,946 --> 00:29:43,490
That's how he knew so much about him.

659
00:29:43,573 --> 00:29:45,492
That's how he could convince Gabrielle

660
00:29:45,575 --> 00:29:47,160
that he  was  him.

661
00:29:47,243 --> 00:29:48,077
He had a...

662
00:29:48,161 --> 00:29:51,164
a virtual manual on how to  be  him.

663
00:29:51,247 --> 00:29:52,999
Look, I'm sorry. I know I told you

664
00:29:53,082 --> 00:29:54,042
that Joel was Nathan.

665
00:29:54,125 --> 00:29:55,001
I was wrong.

666
00:29:55,084 --> 00:29:58,880
I fell for the same scam Gabrielle did.

667
00:29:58,963 --> 00:30:00,215
The only thing I  don't  know

668
00:30:00,298 --> 00:30:03,009
is, if Joel Tiernan was always Joel Tiernan,

669
00:30:03,092 --> 00:30:05,386
why would he kill Robin Aronson?

670
00:30:05,470 --> 00:30:08,056
Maybe because he  didn't kill her, Allison.

671
00:30:08,139 --> 00:30:09,140
What?

672
00:30:09,224 --> 00:30:11,392
Lee brought this in a few minutes before you arrived.

673
00:30:11,476 --> 00:30:13,770
Wait a second. Who's this?

674
00:30:13,853 --> 00:30:16,731
Arthur Kolber. Worked as a maintenance man

675
00:30:16,814 --> 00:30:19,067
at the cottages where Robin Aaronson was beaten to death.

676
00:30:19,150 --> 00:30:22,070
I was doing my due diligence on the hotel staff when I found out

677
00:30:22,153 --> 00:30:24,072
Kolber sexually assaulted

678
00:30:24,155 --> 00:30:26,074
a female friend two months ago.

679
00:30:26,157 --> 00:30:30,286
I had the lab compare  his  blood to the drop that we found

680
00:30:30,370 --> 00:30:32,121
at the scene of Robin Aaronson's murder, and...

681
00:30:32,205 --> 00:30:33,289
guess what.

682
00:30:33,373 --> 00:30:34,415
A perfect match.

683
00:30:34,499 --> 00:30:36,251
Kolber claims he cut his hand

684
00:30:36,334 --> 00:30:37,377
doing repairs at the cottage,

685
00:30:37,460 --> 00:30:38,920
but I don't buy it.

686
00:30:39,003 --> 00:30:40,380
I'm pretty sure this is our guy.

687
00:30:40,463 --> 00:30:43,299
Wait a second.

688
00:30:43,383 --> 00:30:45,134
Even if he didn't kill Robin,

689
00:30:45,218 --> 00:30:46,928
what about everything he's done to Gabrielle,

690
00:30:47,011 --> 00:30:48,137
everything he's put her through?

691
00:30:48,221 --> 00:30:49,264
Can't we get him on that?

692
00:30:49,347 --> 00:30:50,932
On what?

693
00:30:51,015 --> 00:30:52,141
Gabrielle is a full-grown woman.

694
00:30:52,225 --> 00:30:53,726
If she wants to believe that she's married

695
00:30:53,810 --> 00:30:55,270
to the ghost of her dead husband,

696
00:30:55,353 --> 00:30:57,480
well, there's no law against that.

697
00:30:58,815 --> 00:31:00,024
On the other hand,

698
00:31:00,108 --> 00:31:02,110
I... I'd be lying if I said

699
00:31:02,193 --> 00:31:04,779
that I didn't think that Joel Tiernan was hiding something.

700
00:31:04,862 --> 00:31:06,072
But here's the thing--

701
00:31:06,155 --> 00:31:07,407
I already owe the man an apology

702
00:31:07,490 --> 00:31:09,242
for accusing him of killing his sister-in-law.

703
00:31:09,325 --> 00:31:12,787
I certainly can't  also accuse him of perpetrating

704
00:31:12,870 --> 00:31:14,789
one of the cruelest hoaxes I've ever heard of,

705
00:31:14,872 --> 00:31:16,082
especially without proof.

706
00:31:16,165 --> 00:31:19,419
You... don't have any proof, do you?

707
00:31:21,379 --> 00:31:22,630
Yeah, well.

708
00:31:22,714 --> 00:31:23,923
Me neither.

709
00:31:24,007 --> 00:31:25,466
ENRIGHT: I'm sorry. I don't get it.

710
00:31:25,550 --> 00:31:26,884
Your daughter has done

711
00:31:26,968 --> 00:31:29,137
maybe a dozen more explicit drawings of me,

712
00:31:29,220 --> 00:31:31,180
and you want to talk to me about this dot?

713
00:31:31,264 --> 00:31:33,766
I'm not so sure that it is just a dot.

714
00:31:33,850 --> 00:31:35,226
I think that maybe it's a mole.

715
00:31:35,310 --> 00:31:37,312
(laughs)

716
00:31:37,395 --> 00:31:39,480
All right, a mole. So?

717
00:31:39,564 --> 00:31:43,318
So... do you?

718
00:31:43,401 --> 00:31:45,153
Do you have a mole on your chest?

719
00:31:45,236 --> 00:31:46,821
One that's, you know,

720
00:31:46,904 --> 00:31:48,656
in roughly the same spot as these?

721
00:31:48,740 --> 00:31:50,491
You know what? I don't really know.

722
00:31:50,575 --> 00:31:53,036
I've got quite a few moles. Most adults do.

723
00:31:53,119 --> 00:31:55,371
I know, but I'm talking about this one.

724
00:31:55,455 --> 00:31:58,833
You see how it's changing shape in the pictures?

725
00:31:58,916 --> 00:32:01,002
See, it's, like, growing?

726
00:32:01,085 --> 00:32:02,795
I don't mean to alarm you,

727
00:32:02,879 --> 00:32:05,632
but I think that you might want to go see your doctor.

728
00:32:05,715 --> 00:32:08,343
Mr. Dubois, with all due respect to your daughter,

729
00:32:08,426 --> 00:32:09,677
these are doodles.

730
00:32:09,761 --> 00:32:12,013
Now, are you seriously suggesting

731
00:32:12,096 --> 00:32:14,849
that I have myself tested for skin cancer

732
00:32:14,932 --> 00:32:18,019
because of your daughter's doodles?

733
00:32:18,102 --> 00:32:20,271
Actually, I am.

734
00:32:22,649 --> 00:32:23,608
(knocking)

735
00:32:23,691 --> 00:32:24,817
JOEL: Robin, you in there?

736
00:32:24,901 --> 00:32:26,736
ROBIN: Door's open.

737
00:32:26,819 --> 00:32:28,279
(door hinges creak)

738
00:32:30,073 --> 00:32:32,116
I got here as fast as I could.

739
00:32:33,701 --> 00:32:36,079
So why'd you make me drive all the way out here

740
00:32:36,162 --> 00:32:38,706
just to talk to you, hmm?

741
00:32:38,790 --> 00:32:41,042
What is this place?

742
00:32:41,125 --> 00:32:43,294
(door opening) This?

743
00:32:45,088 --> 00:32:47,173
This is our place.

744
00:32:48,925 --> 00:32:51,719
It's so good to see you again, baby.

745
00:32:51,803 --> 00:32:52,887
Robin, what are you doing?

746
00:32:52,970 --> 00:32:54,472
Why are you dressed like that?

747
00:32:55,973 --> 00:32:57,433
Stop!

748
00:32:59,268 --> 00:33:01,229
What's the matter?

749
00:33:01,312 --> 00:33:03,898
I can't do this with you.

750
00:33:03,981 --> 00:33:06,734
I mean, I'm flattered, don't get me wrong.

751
00:33:06,818 --> 00:33:10,113
But I could never betray Gabrielle like that.

752
00:33:12,490 --> 00:33:14,075
(chuckles)

753
00:33:14,158 --> 00:33:17,704
Huh, that's funny.

754
00:33:17,787 --> 00:33:20,915
You never had a problem with it before, Nathan.

755
00:33:20,998 --> 00:33:22,583
What did you just call me?

756
00:33:22,667 --> 00:33:26,087
"Nathan." That's who you really are, isn't it?

757
00:33:26,170 --> 00:33:28,589
Gabrielle told you.

758
00:33:28,673 --> 00:33:32,135
Yeah, she told me. She told me all about you.

759
00:33:32,218 --> 00:33:35,596
Of course, if you were really Nathan,

760
00:33:35,680 --> 00:33:38,725
you'd know about our little secret, wouldn't you?

761
00:33:38,808 --> 00:33:42,145
You'd know that you bought me this negligee,

762
00:33:42,228 --> 00:33:44,105
and you'd know that this place

763
00:33:44,188 --> 00:33:46,816
is where we used to meet

764
00:33:46,899 --> 00:33:49,110
to make love;

765
00:33:49,193 --> 00:33:51,654
to betray my sister.

766
00:33:51,738 --> 00:33:55,450
But you don't remember anything about us, do you?

767
00:33:55,533 --> 00:34:00,705
Because you're not Nathan, you're a fraud.

768
00:34:00,788 --> 00:34:02,957
A parasite.

769
00:34:03,040 --> 00:34:04,292
Wait a minute. You have it wrong.

770
00:34:04,375 --> 00:34:06,627
Shut up!

771
00:34:06,711 --> 00:34:09,297
Stop lying.

772
00:34:09,380 --> 00:34:12,132
I don't know how you managed to trick my sister,

773
00:34:12,216 --> 00:34:15,178
but I'm gonna make sure she knows the truth.

774
00:34:15,261 --> 00:34:17,429
I'm gonna tell her everything.

775
00:34:19,056 --> 00:34:20,099
(thud) (groans)

776
00:34:24,228 --> 00:34:25,605
Your sister loves me, Robin.

777
00:34:25,688 --> 00:34:27,315
She's happy.

778
00:34:27,398 --> 00:34:29,817
You should have left us alone.

779
00:34:30,400 --> 00:34:32,402
(gasps)

780
00:34:38,201 --> 00:34:40,411
Mrs. Tiernan?

781
00:34:42,413 --> 00:34:44,498
I was hoping I could speak with you.

782
00:34:44,581 --> 00:34:48,210
I'm not sure we have much to talk about.

783
00:34:48,293 --> 00:34:49,837
Not unless you're here to apologize

784
00:34:49,920 --> 00:34:51,714
for the way your office has treated my husband.

785
00:34:51,797 --> 00:34:54,550
No, that's not why I'm here.

786
00:34:54,634 --> 00:34:56,761
Obviously, he didn't write about the affair

787
00:34:56,844 --> 00:34:58,513
in his autobiography.

788
00:34:58,596 --> 00:35:00,181
That's why Joel didn't know about it.

789
00:35:00,264 --> 00:35:03,142
So when Robin threatened to expose him,

790
00:35:03,226 --> 00:35:05,686
he didn't really have a choice but to kill her.

791
00:35:05,770 --> 00:35:07,146
Kill her or lose everything.

792
00:35:07,230 --> 00:35:10,316
No... no, you're wrong.

793
00:35:10,399 --> 00:35:11,901
They, they found another man's blood

794
00:35:11,984 --> 00:35:13,110
at the crime scene.

795
00:35:13,194 --> 00:35:15,196
A man who worked at the hotel;

796
00:35:15,279 --> 00:35:16,864
he told the police he cut his hand.

797
00:35:16,948 --> 00:35:18,157
I can't prove it,

798
00:35:18,241 --> 00:35:20,326
but I think he's being honest with us.

799
00:35:20,409 --> 00:35:23,746
The truth is, I can't prove any of this.

800
00:35:23,830 --> 00:35:28,417
But you came to us, you told us you wanted our help.

801
00:35:28,501 --> 00:35:31,754
And I thought you deserved to hear the truth,

802
00:35:31,838 --> 00:35:33,548
even if a jury never does.

803
00:35:33,631 --> 00:35:35,550
Even if it hurts.

804
00:35:35,633 --> 00:35:38,219
Gabrielle,

805
00:35:38,302 --> 00:35:40,221
he's gone.

806
00:35:40,304 --> 00:35:43,599
The man you loved is gone.

807
00:35:43,683 --> 00:35:47,770
And this man isn't him.

808
00:35:50,439 --> 00:35:51,440
(door opens)

809
00:35:54,360 --> 00:35:56,195
(door shuts)

810
00:36:00,324 --> 00:36:02,577
Gabby, I'm back.

811
00:36:02,660 --> 00:36:04,704
Welcome home, Nathan.

812
00:36:04,787 --> 00:36:06,581
It's okay.

813
00:36:06,664 --> 00:36:09,250
Um, you don't have to pretend in front of Mrs. Dubois.

814
00:36:09,333 --> 00:36:11,252
She knows who you really are.

815
00:36:13,504 --> 00:36:16,215
What's she doing here?

816
00:36:16,299 --> 00:36:17,425
After all I've been through

817
00:36:17,508 --> 00:36:18,759
with the district attorney's office,

818
00:36:18,843 --> 00:36:20,636
why would you let that woman in our house?

819
00:36:20,720 --> 00:36:22,555
She came here to talk to me,

820
00:36:22,638 --> 00:36:25,600
to, um, to tell me some things about you.

821
00:36:25,683 --> 00:36:28,936
Some theories she has about you.

822
00:36:29,020 --> 00:36:30,396
What kind of theories?

823
00:36:30,479 --> 00:36:33,816
Why would you listen to her?

824
00:36:33,900 --> 00:36:36,235
We've been together nearly two years.

825
00:36:36,319 --> 00:36:37,570
What could she possibly tell you

826
00:36:37,653 --> 00:36:38,779
that we don't already know?

827
00:36:38,863 --> 00:36:41,157
Well, that's a great question, Nathan.

828
00:36:41,240 --> 00:36:43,242
You don't mind if I call you Nathan, do you?

829
00:36:44,869 --> 00:36:47,747
You know what? I was just flipping through

830
00:36:47,830 --> 00:36:49,707
a couple of your books this morning.

831
00:36:49,790 --> 00:36:52,793
They're beautifully written, Mr. Cafferty.

832
00:36:52,877 --> 00:36:54,754
You really have a way with words

833
00:36:54,837 --> 00:36:57,131
and a, and a very particular style.

834
00:36:57,214 --> 00:36:58,966
You're a wonderful writer.

835
00:36:59,050 --> 00:37:01,260
Thank you.

836
00:37:02,511 --> 00:37:05,097
Anyway, I know this is gonna sound like a...

837
00:37:05,181 --> 00:37:10,144
a strange request, but we were wondering if...

838
00:37:10,228 --> 00:37:12,939
maybe we could get you to sit here

839
00:37:13,022 --> 00:37:16,525
and write something right here, right now.

840
00:37:16,609 --> 00:37:19,236
Now, why would I want to do that?

841
00:37:19,320 --> 00:37:22,907
Well, why  wouldn't  you want to do it?

842
00:37:24,700 --> 00:37:26,994
You know, it's, it's funny.

843
00:37:27,078 --> 00:37:30,665
In the two years since you first walked in that door,

844
00:37:30,748 --> 00:37:34,335
I haven't seen you do a single stitch of work.

845
00:37:34,418 --> 00:37:36,212
I haven't seen you write anything.

846
00:37:36,295 --> 00:37:39,006
And Nathan,

847
00:37:39,090 --> 00:37:45,137
I mean, the original Nathan, he was forever writing things,

848
00:37:45,221 --> 00:37:49,392
reading things to me, showing me things.

849
00:37:53,980 --> 00:37:58,275
So do it for me again, Nathan, like you used to.

850
00:38:29,640 --> 00:38:31,684
Can you even type?

851
00:38:31,767 --> 00:38:34,770
I think I'd like you to leave my house now, Mrs. Dubois.

852
00:38:34,854 --> 00:38:38,232
Actually, this is my house...

853
00:38:38,315 --> 00:38:43,029
and I'd like Allison to stay.

854
00:38:43,112 --> 00:38:44,530
She's invited some of her colleagues over.

855
00:38:44,613 --> 00:38:46,407
They should be here in a minute.

856
00:38:50,619 --> 00:38:52,538
Mrs. Dubois seems to think

857
00:38:52,621 --> 00:38:56,250
that if the police take a look around the, uh, the property,

858
00:38:56,333 --> 00:38:57,501
they may turn up that manuscript

859
00:38:57,585 --> 00:38:59,503
that she says you took from Nathan's car.

860
00:39:04,175 --> 00:39:05,760
We turned the place upside down.

861
00:39:05,843 --> 00:39:08,262
So far, we found nothing.

862
00:39:08,346 --> 00:39:09,889
I'll give it a few more minutes,

863
00:39:09,972 --> 00:39:12,475
but, uh, I think it's just about time to pack it in.

864
00:39:12,558 --> 00:39:15,102
So that's it? He gets away with everything?

865
00:39:15,186 --> 00:39:18,606
Well, everything except Gabrielle.

866
00:39:18,689 --> 00:39:20,149
She asked if we'd escort her husband

867
00:39:20,232 --> 00:39:21,942
from the premises after we're done.

868
00:39:22,026 --> 00:39:25,988
We might not be able to prove Joe Tiernan's a murderer, but...

869
00:39:26,072 --> 00:39:28,407
at least we got him out of her life.

870
00:39:57,728 --> 00:39:59,939
♪ ♪

871
00:40:39,395 --> 00:40:42,064
Lee!

872
00:40:43,399 --> 00:40:44,859
ALLISON: Are the girls down?

873
00:40:44,942 --> 00:40:46,902
Two out of three.

874
00:40:46,986 --> 00:40:48,571
Bridgette's still buzzing about all the nice things

875
00:40:48,654 --> 00:40:51,073
that Mr. Enright had to say about her

876
00:40:51,157 --> 00:40:52,074
after class today;

877
00:40:52,158 --> 00:40:54,535
how she should feel free to draw what she wants

878
00:40:54,618 --> 00:40:55,536
when she wants.

879
00:40:55,619 --> 00:40:56,537
Mm.

880
00:40:56,620 --> 00:40:57,538
Call me crazy.

881
00:40:57,621 --> 00:40:59,081
I think somebody got some good news

882
00:40:59,165 --> 00:41:00,166
from their dermatologist.

883
00:41:00,249 --> 00:41:01,167
What is this?

884
00:41:01,250 --> 00:41:03,210
It's a little picture of us that Bridgette drew

885
00:41:03,294 --> 00:41:05,045
before she went to bed.

886
00:41:05,129 --> 00:41:06,755
I looked very closely. There's no lumps,

887
00:41:06,839 --> 00:41:10,551
growths or vestigial limbs on either of us,

888
00:41:10,634 --> 00:41:13,220
so I assume we're in the pink of health.

889
00:41:13,304 --> 00:41:15,014
She even gave us clothes.

890
00:41:15,097 --> 00:41:16,348
Hmm.

891
00:41:16,432 --> 00:41:17,850
Hey, did I tell you

892
00:41:17,933 --> 00:41:20,102
that I took a life-drawing class in college?

893
00:41:20,186 --> 00:41:22,396
No, you didn't. Yes, I did.

894
00:41:22,480 --> 00:41:23,939
Yeah? Mm.

895
00:41:24,023 --> 00:41:25,274
You ever done any modeling?

896
00:41:25,357 --> 00:41:27,276
Get used to these boxers, babe,

897
00:41:27,359 --> 00:41:28,402
'cause they're never coming off.

898
00:41:28,485 --> 00:41:31,780
Oh, come on. You got something against art, hmm?

899
00:41:31,864 --> 00:41:33,699
I'm telling you. You've got a little something.

900
00:41:33,782 --> 00:41:34,617
Oh, yeah?

901
00:41:34,700 --> 00:41:37,328
I just need to get my crayons. (laughs)